Arrow Pushers
← All chapters
6MxEnergy & Mechanisms
Chapter 6 notes and study guide

Chemical Reactivity and Mechanisms

Enthalpy, entropy, free energy, equilibrium, kinetics, energy diagrams, nucleophiles and electrophiles, and the four arrow-pushing patterns.

Notes

7 lessons. Tap a molecule to see it in 3D.

Thermodynamics: will the reaction go?

Enthalpy, entropy and free energy, and how they set the position of equilibrium.

Thermodynamics compares the energy of the starting materials with the energy of the products. It tells you where the equilibrium lies. It says nothing about how long the reaction takes.

Enthalpy (ΔH)

Breaking a bond costs energy and forming a bond releases it. So:

RuleΔH ≈ energy of bonds broken − energy of bonds formed

If the new bonds are stronger than the old ones, ΔH is negative and the reaction is exothermic (releases heat). If they are weaker, ΔH is positive and it is endothermic.

ExothermicEnergyReaction progressEaΔH < 0reactantstransition state ‡productsEndothermicEnergyReaction progressEaΔH > 0reactantstransition state ‡products
Ea is the height of the hill. ΔH is the difference between the start and the finish.

Entropy (ΔS)

Entropy measures how spread out the energy and matter are. ΔS is positive when a reaction makes more molecules than it uses (one molecule splitting into two), when a ring opens, or when a gas forms.

Free energy (ΔG) puts them together

RuleΔG = ΔH − TΔS

A negative ΔG means products are favored at equilibrium. The link to the equilibrium constant is ΔG° = −RT ln K. A useful number to remember: at room temperature, every 5.7 kJ/mol of ΔG° changes K by a factor of ten.

Because ΔS is multiplied by temperature, entropy matters more when it is hot. This is why heat favors elimination over substitution in Chapter 7: elimination makes more molecules, so it has the larger ΔS.

Exam trapExothermic does not mean fast. Burning paper is very exothermic, yet paper sits in air for decades. Speed is a separate question, answered by kinetics.

Kinetics: how fast?

Activation energy, rate laws, and what a catalyst does.

Kinetics is about the rate of a reaction. The rate is set by the activation energy (Ea): the energy needed to climb from the reactants to the highest-energy arrangement along the way, the transition state.

  • A low Ea means many collisions have enough energy to react, so the reaction is fast.
  • A high Ea means the reaction is slow, however favorable the products are.

What changes the rate

  • Temperature. Heating gives more molecules enough energy to get over the barrier. A common rule of thumb is that the rate roughly doubles for every 10 °C.
  • Concentration. More molecules means more collisions, according to the rate law.
  • A catalyst. It provides a different pathway with a lower Ea.
EnergyReaction progresswithout catalystwith catalystreactantsproducts
A catalyst speeds up the forward and reverse reactions equally. It does not change ΔG, and it does not move the equilibrium.

Rate laws

A rate law says how the rate depends on concentration. It comes from the mechanism, specifically from whatever takes part in the slowest step.

  • rate = k[A][B] is second order overall. Both A and B are involved in the slow step. Doubling either one doubles the rate.
  • rate = k[A] is first order. Only A is involved in the slow step. Changing [B] does nothing.

This is where SN2 (second order) and SN1 (first order) get the numbers in their names.

TipA reaction can be kinetically controlled (the product that forms fastest wins) or thermodynamically controlled (the most stable product wins). Low temperature and short times favor the kinetic product.

Reading energy diagrams

Transition states, intermediates, and how to find the rate-determining step.

An energy diagram plots energy against the progress of the reaction. Almost every mechanism question can be answered by reading one correctly.

EnergyReaction progressEareactantsTS 1 ‡ (highest point)intermediateTS 2 ‡products

The features

  • Transition state (‡): a peak. It is the highest-energy point of a step, with bonds partly broken and partly formed. It exists for about one molecular vibration and can never be isolated.
  • Intermediate: a valley between two peaks. It is a real species with fully formed bonds, such as a carbocation. It is short-lived, but it exists.
  • Number of steps = number of peaks. Number of intermediates = number of valleys between them.
  • Rate-determining step: the step with the highest-energy transition state. The whole reaction can go no faster than this step.

Transition state versus intermediate

Students mix these up constantly, so here is the test. Can you draw it with normal, complete bonds? Then it is an intermediate. Does it need dashed partial bonds and partial charges in brackets? Then it is a transition state.

Exam trapThe rate-determining step is not always the first step and not always the one with the biggest single hill. It is the one whose peak is the highest point on the whole diagram.

The Hammond postulate

How to guess what a transition state looks like, and why that matters.

You cannot observe a transition state, but you can estimate its structure. The Hammond postulate says that a transition state resembles whichever stable species it is closest to in energy.

Exothermic stepEnergyReaction progressearly TS: looks like reactantsreactantsproductsEndothermic stepEnergyReaction progresslate TS: looks like productsreactantsproducts
  • In an exothermic step, the transition state comes early and looks like the reactants.
  • In an endothermic step, the transition state comes late and looks like the products.

Why you should care

Forming a carbocation is strongly endothermic, so the transition state leading to it looks a lot like the carbocation. Anything that stabilizes the carbocation also stabilizes that transition state, which lowers Ea and speeds up the step.

That single idea explains several results later in the course:

  • Tertiary halides undergo SN1 faster than secondary ones, because the tertiary carbocation is more stable.
  • A proton adds to an alkene so as to give the more stable carbocation (Markovnikov's rule).
TipWhen a question asks why the more stable intermediate forms faster, the answer is the Hammond postulate. Stability of the intermediate is thermodynamics. Hammond is the bridge that lets you use it to predict rate.

Nucleophiles and electrophiles

The two roles in almost every organic reaction.

Most reactions in this course are an electron-rich species reacting with an electron-poor one.

  • A nucleophile ("nucleus-loving") donates an electron pair to form a new bond. It has a lone pair or a π bond, and is often negatively charged.
  • An electrophile ("electron-loving") accepts an electron pair. It has a positive charge, a partial positive charge or an empty orbital.
hydroxide: lone pairs, negative
ammonia: lone pair
cyanide
an alkene: π electrons

Nucleophiles.

a carbocation: empty p orbital
bromomethane: carbon is δ+
acetone: carbonyl carbon is δ+

Electrophiles.

Curved arrows always run from the nucleophile to the electrophile. If your arrow starts at a positive charge, it is backward.

Nucleophile or base?

The same species can do both jobs. The difference is what it attacks.

  • Acting as a base, it attacks a hydrogen. Basicity is about equilibrium and is measured by pKa.
  • Acting as a nucleophile, it attacks a carbon (or another non-hydrogen atom). Nucleophilicity is about rate.

Size and polarizability matter for nucleophilicity. Large atoms such as iodine and sulfur have loosely held electrons that reach out easily, so I⁻ and HS⁻ are excellent nucleophiles even though they are weak bases. A bulky species such as tert-butoxide is a strong base but a poor nucleophile, because it cannot get close to a carbon. This distinction decides substitution versus elimination in Chapter 7.

The four arrow-pushing patterns

Every ionic mechanism in the course is built from these four moves.

Mechanisms look complicated until you notice that only four things ever happen. Learn to recognize each one and you can follow, and predict, any multi-step mechanism.

1. Nucleophilic attackBr⁻C⁺CH₃CH₃H₃Ca lone pair or π bond attacks an electron-poor atom2. Loss of a leaving groupCCH₃H₃CCH₃Brgives C⁺ + Br⁻the bonding pair leaves with the leaving group3. Proton transferHO⁻HCla base takes H⁺, the H–X pair stays behind on X4. RearrangementCC⁺HH₃CCH₃HCH₃H or CH₃ shifts with its bonding pair to the C⁺ next door
  • 1. Nucleophilic attack. A lone pair or π bond attacks an electrophile and forms a new σ bond. One arrow (two if a π bond has to move out of the way).
  • 2. Loss of a leaving group. A bond breaks and both electrons leave with the leaving group. One arrow.
  • 3. Proton transfer. A base removes H⁺. Always two arrows: base to H, then the H–X bond onto X.
  • 4. Rearrangement. A hydrogen or alkyl group on the carbon next to a carbocation slides over with its bonding pair, giving a more stable carbocation. One arrow.

Putting them in sequence

A mechanism is these moves in order. SN1 is loss of a leaving group followed by nucleophilic attack, often finished with a proton transfer. SN2 is nucleophilic attack and loss of a leaving group at the same instant. E2 is a proton transfer and loss of a leaving group at the same instant.

TipWhen you are stuck on a mechanism, ask what the reagent is. An acid means the first step is a proton transfer. A good nucleophile means attack. A good leaving group on a tertiary carbon in a weak nucleophile means it will leave first.

Carbocations and rearrangements

Structure, stability order, and when a hydride or methyl shift happens.

A carbocation is a carbon with three bonds and a positive charge. It has only six valence electrons. It is sp² hybridized and flat, with an empty p orbital sticking out above and below the plane.

tert-butyl cation: the three carbons around C⁺ lie in one plane

Because it is flat, a nucleophile can attack from either face.

Stability

methyl: least stable
primary (1°)
secondary (2°)
tertiary (3°): most stable

Alkyl groups stabilize the positive charge by hyperconjugation: electrons in neighboring C–H and C–C σ bonds overlap slightly with the empty p orbital and share their density with it. More alkyl groups mean more of these overlaps.

Resonance stabilizes even more strongly. An allylic or benzylic carbocation spreads its charge over several atoms, so a primary allylic cation is about as stable as a secondary alkyl one.

↔

The allyl cation.

Rearrangements

If moving a hydrogen or a methyl group from the neighboring carbon would create a more stable carbocation, it happens, and it happens fast.

H₃CCCH⁺CH₃CH₃H2° carbocation1,2-hydride shiftH₃CC⁺CH₂CH₃CH₃3° carbocation, more stable
A 1,2-hydride shift. The H moves with both electrons of its bond.
  • A 1,2-hydride shift moves an H. A 1,2-methyl shift moves a CH₃, and is used when the neighboring carbon has no H to give.
  • A shift happens only if the result is more stable: 2° to 3°, or to a resonance-stabilized position.
  • Methyl and primary carbocations are too unstable to form at all under normal conditions.
Exam trapWhenever a mechanism goes through a carbocation (SN1, E1, HX addition, acid-catalyzed hydration), look at the neighboring carbons before drawing the product. If a shift can give a better cation, the major product comes from the rearranged one.

Key ideas

The chapter on one page

Thermodynamics: will it go?

  • ΔH from bonds: ΔH = (bonds broken) − (bonds formed). Negative = exothermic.
  • ΔS: more molecules or more freedom means positive ΔS. One molecule becoming two is positive. A ring opening is positive.
  • ΔG = ΔH − TΔS. Negative ΔG = spontaneous (exergonic).
  • ΔG = −RT ln K. Negative ΔG ↔ K > 1. Every 5.7 kJ/mol at 25 °C is a factor of 10 in K.
  • High temperature makes the TΔS term matter more.

Kinetics: how fast?

  • Rate depends on the activation energy (Ea), temperature, concentration and sterics.
  • Lower Ea = faster. A catalyst lowers Ea and leaves ΔG and K untouched.
  • The rate-determining step is the one with the highest-energy transition state.
  • Thermodynamics and kinetics are independent. A reaction can be very favorable and still slow.

Reading energy diagrams

  • Peaks are transition states (cannot be isolated). Valleys are intermediates.
  • Number of steps = number of peaks.
  • Kinetic product: forms fastest (lowest Ea). Thermodynamic product: most stable (lowest energy).
  • Low temperature favors the kinetic product. Higher temperature and time favor the thermodynamic product.

Hammond postulate

  • A transition state resembles the species closest to it in energy.
  • Exothermic step → early TS, looks like reactants. Endothermic step → late TS, looks like products.
  • So anything that stabilizes a carbocation also stabilizes the TS leading to it.

Nucleophiles and electrophiles

  • Nucleophile: electron-rich, donates a pair (lone pairs, π bonds). A Lewis base.
  • Electrophile: electron-poor, accepts a pair (C⁺, δ⁺ carbon attached to a leaving group, C=O carbon). A Lewis acid.
  • Bigger, more polarizable atoms are better nucleophiles.

The four arrow-pushing patterns

  • 1. Nucleophilic attack
  • 2. Loss of a leaving group
  • 3. Proton transfer
  • 4. Carbocation rearrangement (hydride or methyl shift)
  • Every ionic mechanism in this course is some sequence of these four.

Carbocations

  • Stability: 3° > 2° > 1° > methyl, thanks to hyperconjugation from neighboring C–H and C–C bonds.
  • Allylic and benzylic cations are stabilized by resonance.
  • A carbocation rearranges only if a 1,2-shift produces a more stable cation.

Flashcards

42 cards

Thermodynamics & kineticsDrill this deck

PromptAnswer
ΔH from bond dissociation energiesΔH = Σ BDE (bonds broken) − Σ BDE (bonds formed)
ExothermicΔH is negative. Heat is released; products have stronger bonds.
EndothermicΔH is positive. Heat is absorbed.
Gibbs free energy equationΔG = ΔH − TΔS
Exergonic versus endergonicExergonic: ΔG < 0, spontaneous. Endergonic: ΔG > 0, not spontaneous.
Sign of ΔS when one molecule splits into twoPositive
Sign of ΔS when two molecules combine into oneNegative
Sign of ΔS when a ring opens to a chainPositive. More conformational freedom.
Relationship between ΔG and KΔG = −RT ln K. Negative ΔG means K > 1 and products are favored.
What ΔG gives K = 1?ΔG = 0
How much ΔG shifts K by a factor of 10 at 25 °C?About 5.7 kJ/mol
ΔH negative and ΔS positiveSpontaneous at every temperature
ΔH positive and ΔS negativeNever spontaneous
ΔH negative and ΔS negativeSpontaneous only at low temperature
ΔH positive and ΔS positiveSpontaneous only at high temperature
Activation energy (Ea)The energy gap between reactants and the transition state. It sets the rate.
What does a catalyst change?It lowers Ea and speeds the reaction. It does not change ΔG, ΔH or K.
Transition state versus intermediateTransition state: an energy maximum, exists for an instant. Intermediate: an energy minimum, has a real lifetime.
Rate-determining stepThe step with the highest-energy transition state
Kinetic productThe product that forms fastest (lowest Ea). Favored at low temperature.
Thermodynamic productThe most stable product (lowest energy). Favored at high temperature and long reaction times.
Hammond postulateA transition state resembles whichever species, reactant or product, is closer to it in energy.
Rough rule for temperature and rateRaising the temperature by 10 °C roughly doubles the rate.
Homolytic versus heterolytic cleavageHomolytic: each atom keeps one electron (radicals, fishhook arrows). Heterolytic: one atom keeps both (ions).

Arrow pushing, nucleophiles & carbocationsDrill this deck

PromptAnswer
NucleophileAn electron-rich species that donates an electron pair to form a bond
ElectrophileAn electron-poor species that accepts an electron pair
Typical nucleophilic sitesLone pairs, π bonds, negatively charged atoms
Typical electrophilic sitesCarbocations, carbons bearing a leaving group, carbonyl carbons
The four arrow-pushing patternsNucleophilic attack · loss of a leaving group · proton transfer · carbocation rearrangement
Nucleophilic attackAn arrow from the nucleophile's electrons to the electrophile, forming a new bond
Loss of a leaving groupAn arrow from the C–LG bond onto the leaving group, which departs with both electrons
Proton transferTwo arrows: base to H, and the H–A bond onto A
Hydride shiftAn H moves with its bonding pair to the neighboring C⁺, creating a more stable carbocation
Methyl shiftA CH₃ moves with its bonding pair to the neighboring C⁺, creating a more stable carbocation
Carbocation stability order3° > 2° > 1° > methyl
Why are more substituted carbocations more stable?Hyperconjugation: neighboring C–H and C–C σ bonds donate into the empty p orbital.
When does a carbocation rearrange?Only when a 1,2-shift gives a more stable carbocation, such as 2° to 3° or to a resonance-stabilized cation.
Allylic and benzylic carbocationsStabilized by resonance with the adjacent π system
What makes a nucleophile stronger?Negative charge, and larger, more polarizable atoms (I⁻, HS⁻)
How many curved arrows for nucleophilic attack on a carbonyl?Two: one into the carbon, one pushing the π bond onto oxygen
ConcertedBond making and bond breaking happen in one step, with no intermediate
Reversible versus irreversible arrowsUse equilibrium arrows when both directions matter. Use a one-way arrow when the products are far more stable.

Practice questions

A sample of the 36 in this chapter. Open one to check your answer.

Enthalpy, entropy & free energyTake the quiz (10 questions)

(CH₃)₃C–H + Cl₂ → (CH₃)₃C–Cl + HCl. BDEs in kJ/mol: C–H 381, Cl–Cl 243, C–Cl 331, H–Cl 431. What is ΔH?

Answer: −138 kJ/mol

Broken: 381 + 243 = 624. Formed: 331 + 431 = 762. ΔH = 624 − 762.

A reaction forms stronger bonds than it breaks. The reaction is…

Answer: exothermic

Forming strong bonds releases more energy than breaking the weak ones costs.

What is the sign of ΔS for A → B + C?

Answer: Positive

One molecule becoming two increases disorder.

Kinetics & energy diagramsTake the quiz (10 questions)

What determines the rate of a reaction step?

Answer: Its activation energy

Rate is about the height of the barrier, not the energy difference between start and finish.

A catalyst…

Answer: lowers Ea without changing ΔG

It provides a lower-energy pathway to the same products.

An energy diagram has three peaks. How many intermediates does the mechanism have?

Answer: 2

Three steps mean three transition states with two valleys between them.

Nucleophiles, electrophiles & arrow patternsTake the quiz (11 questions)

Which species is a nucleophile?

Answer: HO⁻

Hydroxide has lone pairs and a negative charge to donate. The others are electron-poor.

Which site is electrophilic?

Answer: The carbon of a C–Br bond

Bromine pulls electron density away, leaving the carbon δ⁺.

A π bond attacks H–Br to form a carbocation and Br⁻. For the alkene, this pattern is…

Answer: nucleophilic attack

The π electrons are the nucleophile and the proton is the electrophile.